Populism, Constitution Making, and the Rule of Law in Latin America


Abstract


The article explores the effects of populist polarization in creating strong and long-lasting institutions based on the rule of law. It focuses on politics and not on the political economy of populism or of natural resource extraction. The first section briefly explains how we understand the contested notions of populism and the rule of law. The second focuses on the paradigmatic case of Juan Perón's first two administrations (1946-1956) to explore the ambiguous legacies of populist inclusion for the creation of long-lasting demo-cratic institutions. The third section focuses on how Hugo Chávez, Evo Morales and Rafael Correa appealed to the un-bounded will of the people to convene participatory constituent assemblies. The last section focuses on Ecuador's post-populist succession. Different from Evo Morales that was ousted by a coup, or Nicolás Maduro that killed democracy, Lenín Moreno, who was Correa's former vice-president, abandoned populism, ditched his mentor, and used a referendum to clean the state and political institutions from Correa's allies. Appealing to the people directly, his administration assumed exceptional powers to name new authorities of control and accountability. His institutional reforms however might not last because they were based on the exclusion of Correa and his followers. The conclusion explores the reasons why actors continue to use laws instrumentally making it difficult to create long-lasting institutional arrangements based on the rule of law, and hence on the possibility of deepening democracy.

DOI Code: 10.1285/i20356609v13i3p1453

Keywords: Chávez; Correa; Latin America; Left populism; Morales; Peronism

References


Archondo, Rafael (2020), ‘¿Fue golpe? Pulsando el debate sobre la supuesta fascistización de Bolivia’, Revista Euro Latinoamericana de Análisis Social y Político 1 (1), 245-260.

Aslanidis, Paris (2020), ‘Major directions in populism studies: is there room for culture?’, Partecipazione e conflitto, 13(1), 59-82.

Azellini, Dario (2010), ‘Un poder constituyente en movimiento’, in Francesca Ramos Pimataro, Carlos A. Romero, and Hugo Eduardo Ramírez (eds.), Hugo Chávez: Una Década en el Poder, Arcos, Rosario: Universidad Nacional de Rosario, 107-129.

Baehr, Peter (2008), Caesarism, Charisma and Fate. Historical Sources and Modern Resonances in the Work of Max Weber, New Brunswick: Transaction Press.

Burbano de Lara, Felipe (2014), La Revuelta de las Periferias, Quito: FLACSO.

Burbano de Lara, Felipe (2019), ‘Populist waves in Latin America: continuities, Twists, and Ruptures’ in Carlos de la Torre (ed.), The Routledge International Handbook of Global Populism, New York: Routledge, 435-451.

Burbano de Lara, Felipe and de la Torre Carlos (2020), ‘The Pushback Against Populism: Why Ecuador's Referendums Backfired’, Journal of Democracy 31 (2), 69-80.

Cannon, Barry (2004), ‘Venezuela, April 2002: Coup or Popular Rebellion? The Myth of a United Venezuela’, Bulletin of Latin American Research 23(3), 285-302.

Corrales, Javier (2015), ‘Autocratic Legalism in Venezuela’, Journal of Democracy 26, (2), 37-51.

Combellas, Ricardo (2010), ‘La Venezuela de la V República: la reforma política y sus implicaciones institucionales’, in Martín Tanaka and Francine Jácome (eds.), Desafíos de la Gobernabilidad Democrática, Lima: Instituto de Estudios Peruanos, 149-175.

Coronil, Fernando (2011), ‘Venezuela’s Wounded Bodies: Nation and Imagination During the 2002 Coup’, NACLA 44 (1), 33-39.

de la Torre, Carlos (2010), Populist Seduction in Latin America, Athens Ohio University Press, second edition.

de la Torre, Carlos (2019) (ed.), The Routledge International Handbook of Global Populism, New York: Routledge.

de la Torre, Carlos, and Andrés Ortiz (2016), ‘Populist polarization and the slow death of democracy in Ecuador’, Democratization, 23 (2), 221-241.

Finchelstein, Federico (2014), The Ideological Origins of the Dirty War, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Gargarella, Roberto (2017), ‘The New Latin American Constitutionalism: Old Wine in New Skins’, in edited by Armin von Bogdandy, Eduardo Ferrer Mac- Gregor, Mariela Morales Antoniazzi, and Flávia Piovesan (eds.), Transformative Constitutionalism in Latin America, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 211-235.

Hawkins, Kirk (2016), ‘Responding to Radical Populism: Chavism in Venezuela’, Democratization 23 (2), 242-262.

Henisch, Holtz-Bacha and Oscar Mazzoleni (2017), Political Populism. A Handbook, Baden-Baden: Nomos.

James, Daniel (1988), Resistance and Integration. Peronism and the Argentine Working Class 1946-1976, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Levitsky, Steven and Murillo María Victoria (2009), ‘Variation in Institutional Strength’, The Annual Review of Political Science 12, 115-133.

Levitsky, Steven and Daniel Ziblatt (2018), How Democracies Die, New York: Crown.

López Maya, Margarita (2018), ‘Populism, 21st-century socialism and corruption in Venezuela’, Thesis Eleven, 149 (1), 67-83.

López Maya, Margarita and Panzarelli, Alexandra (2013), ‘Populism, Rentierism, and Socialism in the Twenty First Century.’ in Carlos de la Torre and Cynthia Arnson (eds.), Latin American Populism in the Twenty First Century, Baltimore and Washington: The Johns Hopkins University and the Woodrow Wilson Center Press 2013, 239-269.

Mouffe, Chantal (2018), For Left Populism. London: Verso.

Mudde, Cas and Cristóbal Rovira Kaltwasser (2012), Populism in Europe and the Americas. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Ochoa Espejo, Paulina (2015), ‘Power to Whom? The People between Procedure and Populism’, in Carlos de la Torre (ed.), The Promise and Perils of Populism, Lexington: Kentucky University Press, 74-75.

O’Donnell, Guillermo (1999), ‘Polarchies and the (un)Rule of Law in Latin America: A Partial Conclusion. in Juan Méndez, Guillermo O’Donnell , and Paulo Sergio Pinheiro (eds.) The (Un) Rule of Law and the Underpriviledged in Latin America, Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 303-39.

Paz Gonzales, Eduardo (2020), ‘De golpes y fraudes. Análisis del campo de fuerza en la Boliva post Evo Morales’ Revista Euro Latinoamericana de Análisis Social y Político 1 (1), 227-243.

Peruzzoti, Enrique (2019), ‘Peronism and the Birth of Modern Populism’, Journal of Interregional Studies: Regional and Global Perspectives 2, 4-16.

Plotkin, Mariano (2003), Mañana es San Perón. A Cultural History of Peron’s Argentina, Wilmington, Scholarly Resources.

Plotkin, Mariano (2010), ‘Final Reflections’, in M. Karush y O. Chamosa (ed.) The New Cultural History of Peronism, Durham: Duke University Press, 271-287.

Postero, Nancy (2015), ‘El Pueblo Boliviano de Composición Plural. A look at Plurinational Bolivia’, in Carlos de la Torre (ed.), The Promise and Perils of Populism. Global Perspectives, Lexington: The University Press of Kentucky, 398-431.

Roberts, Kenneth (2019), ‘Bipolar Disorders: Varieties of Capitalism and Populist Out-Flanking on the Left and Right’, Polity 51 (4), 668-77.

Rovira Kaltwasser, Cristóbal, Paul Taggart, Paulina Ochoa Espejo and Pierre Ostiguy (eds.) (2017), The Oxford Handbook of Populism, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Schamis, Héctor (2013), “From the Peróns to the Kirchners. ‘Populism? In Argentine Politics,” in Carlos de la Torre and Cynthia Arnson (eds.), Latin American Populism in the Twenty-First Century, Washington and Baltimore, The Woodrow Wilson Centre Press and The Johns Hopkins University Press, 145-179.

Tórrez, Yuri and Lazcano Emma (2020), ‘Evo no estás solo. El populismo del evismo en Bolivia’, Revista Euro Latinoamericana de Análisis Social y Político 1 (1), 261-275.

Urbinati, Nadia (2019), Me the People. How Populism Transforms Democracy, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Weyland, Kurt (2013), ‘The Threat form the Populist Left’, Journal of Democracy, 24(3), 18-33.

Weyland, Kurt (2020), ‘Populism’s Threat to Democracy: Comparative Lessons for the United States’, Perspectives on Politics 18 (2), 389-406.

Wolff, Jonas (2016), ‘New Constitutions and the Transformation of Democracy in Bolivia and Ecuador’, in Almut Schilling-Vacaflor, and Detlef Nolte, New Constitutionalism in Latin America, London: Routledge, Apple Book, 799-883.


Full Text: PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.
Bookmark and Share


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate 3.0 Italia License.