Email this article Dramatising Crisis. Rhetorical Responses to the COVID-19 Pandemic by Right-Wing Populist Leaders in the USA and UK
Abstract
Building on the theoretical lens of Critical Discourse Analysis and Conceptual Metaphor Theory, this paper examines the rhetorical responses to the COVID-19 pandemic of two right-wing populist leaders whose management of the emergency has been viewed as controversial, namely former American President Donald J. Trump and UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson. Through the critical examination of a dataset of speeches, press conferences and social media posts, and focusing on the discursive strategies employed in framing the pandemic, attributing responsibility, people-building, and policy-making, our study reveals that through different trajectories, the two leaders attempted to exploit the emergency to perform a “crisis within the crisis” in the typical populist style to serve their political interests, based on Moffitt’s (2015) framework. In his trademark style, Trump used the pandemic as a stage to call out and blame multiple enemies both at home (the Congress, the media) and abroad (China). On the other hand, Johnson, who, unlike Trump, did not lend an ear to conspiratorial thinking but still initially minimised the extent of the danger, framed the pandemic as the fight of a nation “walking alone” in a nationalist sense.
References
Ajzen I. 1988, Models of Human Social Behaviour and Their Application to Health Psychology, in “Psychology and Health” 13 [4], pp. 735-739.
Arditi B. 2007, Politics on the Edges of Liberalism: Difference, Populism, Revolution, Agitation, Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh.
Austin J.L. 1962, How to Do Things with Words, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Barr R.R. 2009, Populists, Outsiders and Anti-Establishment Politics, in “Party Politics”
[1], pp. 29-48.
Bauman Z. 2012, Liquid Modernity, Polity, London.
Bennett S. 2019, ‘Crisis’ as a Discursive Strategy in Brexit Referendum Campaigns, in
“Critical Discourse Studies” 16 [4], pp. 449-464.
Bieber F. 2020, Global Nationalism in Times of the COVID-19 Pandemic, in
“Nationalities Papers” 50 [1], pp. 13-25.
Boseley S., Giuffrida A., Davies C., Chrisafis A. and Grytsenko O. 2018, Rightwing
Populists Ride Wave of Mistrust of Vaccine Science, in “The Guardian” December 21 2018. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/dec/21/rightwing-populists-ride- wave-of-mistrust-of-vaccine-science (10.10.2021).
Brändle V.K., Galpin C. and Trenz H.-J. 2021, Brexit as ‘Politics of Division’: Social Media Campaigning after the Referendum, in “Social Movement Studies” 21 [1-2], pp. 234-253.
Canovan M. 1981, Populism, Junction Books, London.
Canovan M. 1999, Trust the People! Populism and the Two Faces of Democracy, in
“Political Studies” 47 [1], pp. 2-16.
Chadwick N. 2003, The Hybrid Media System. Politics and Power, Oxford University
Press, Oxford.
Charteris-Black J. 2006, Britain as a Container: Immigration Metaphors in the 2005
Election Campaign, in “Discourse & Society” 17 [5], pp. 563-581.
Charteris-Black J. 2011, Politicians and Rhetoric. The Persuasive Power of Metaphor,
Palgrave Macmillan, London.
Charteris-Black J. 2021, Metaphors of Coronavirus. Invisible Enemy or Zombie
Apocalypse, Palgrave Macmillan, London.
Chilton P. 2004, Analysing Political Discourse: Theory and Practice, Routledge, London. Coman I.A., Elsheikh D., Gregor M., Lilleker D. and Novelli E. 2021, Introduction:
Political Communication, Governance, and Rhetoric in Times of Crisis, in Lilleker D., Coman I.A., Gregor M. and Novelli E. (eds.) Political Communication and COVID-19. Governance and Rhetoric in Times of Crisis, Routledge, London, pp. 1- 15.
Demata M. 2018, “I think that maybe I wouldn’t be here if it wasn’t for Twitter.”: Donald Trump’s Populist Style on Twitter, in “Textus” XXX [1], pp. 67-90.
De Pryck K. and Gemenne F. 2017, The Denier-in-Chief: Climate Change, Science and the Election of Donald J. Trump, in “Law Critique” 28 [2], pp. 119-126.
Eberl J.-M., Huber R.A. and Greussing E. 2021, From Populism to the “Plandemic”: Why Populists Believe in COVID-19 Conspiracies, in “Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties” 31 [S1], pp. 272-284.
Edelman M. 1964, The Symbolic Uses of Politics, University of Illinois Press, Urbana/Chicago, IL.
Edelman M. 1971. Politics as Symbolic Action: Mass Arousal and Quiescence, Academic Press, New York, NY.
Edelman M. 1977, Political Language. Words that Succeed and Policies that Fail, Academic Press, New York, NY.
Engesser S., Ernst N., Esser F. and Büchel F. 2017, Populism and Social Media: How Politicians Spread a Fragmented Ideology, in “Information, Communication & Society” 20 [8], pp. 1109-1226.
Eysenbach G. 2002, Infodemiology: The Epidemiology of (Mis)information, in “The American Journal of Medicine” 113 [9], pp. 740-745.
Eysenbach G. 2020, How to Fight an Infodemic: The Four Pillars of Infodemic Management, in “Journal of Medical Internet Research” 22 [6], pp. 1-6.
Fairclough N. 2010, Critical Discourse Analysis. The Critical Study of Language, Routledge, London.
Filardo-Llamas L. 2021, From the War on Covid-19 to Political Wars. Metaphor as a Mechanism of Polarization in the Early Stages of the 2020 Pandemic, in Filardo- Llamas L., Morales-López E. and Floyd A. (eds.) Discursive Approaches to Sociopolitical Polarization and Conflict, Routledge, London, pp. 192-212.
Fillmore C.J. 1982, Frame Semantics, in The Linguistic Society of Korea (ed). Linguistics in the Morning Calm, Hanshin Publishing Company, Seoul, pp. 111-137.
Flinders M. 2019, Not a Brexit Election? Pessimism, Promises and Populism ‘UK-Style’, in Tonge J., Wilks-Heeg S. and Thompson L. (eds.) Britain Votes: The 2019 General Election, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 225-242.
Flusberg S.J., Matlock T. and Thibodeau P.H. 2018, War Metaphors in Public Discourse, in “Metaphor & Symbol” 33, pp. 1-18.
Forchtner B. and Özvatan Ö. 2022, De/legitimising EUrope through the Performance of Crises. The Far-Right Alternative for Germany on “climate hysteria” and “corona hysteria”, in “Journal of Language and Politics” 21 [2], pp. 208-232.
Freeden M. 1996, Ideologies and Political Theory: A Conceptual Approach, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Gardini, G. (ed.) 2020, The World Before and After COVID-19. Intellectual Reflections on Politics, Diplomacy and International Relations, European Institute of International Studies Press, Salamanca.
Gerbaudo P. 2020, Coronavirus Embarrassed Trump and Bolsonaro. But the Global Right will Fight Back, in “The Guardian”, April 1 2020. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/apr/01/populist-right-coronavirus (10.10.2021).
Greenaway L. 2020, Group Threat, in Jetten J., Reicher S.D., Haslam S.A. and Cruwys T. (eds.) Together Apart. The Psychology of COVID-19, SAGE, London, pp. 61-67.
t’ Hart P. 1993, Symbols, Rituals and Power: The Lost Dimensions of Crisis Management, in “Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management” 1 [1], pp. 36-50.
Hawkins K.A. and Rovira Kaltwasser C. 2017, The Ideational Approach to Populism, in “Latin American Research Review” 52 [4], pp. 513-528.
Hofstadter R. 1963, Anti-Intellectualism in American Life, Knopf, New York, NY.
Hswen Y., Xu X., Hing A., Hawkins J.B., Brownstein J.S. and Gee G.C. 2021, Association of “#covid19” versus “#chinesevirus” with Anti-Asian Sentiment on
Twitter: March 9-23 2020, in “AJPH” 11 [5], pp. 956-964.
Jetten J., Reicher S.D., Haslam S.A. and Cruwys T. 2020, Together Apart. The Psychology
of COVID-19, SAGE, London.
Jolley D., Douglas K.M. and Sutton R.M. 2018, Blaming a Few Bad Apples to Save a
Threatened Barrel: The System-Justifying Function of Conspiracy Theories, in “Political Psychology” 39 [2], pp. 465-478.
Kahn L. 2020, Who’s in Charge? Leadership during Epidemics, Bioterror Attacks, and Other Public Health Crises, Praeger Security International, Santa Barbara, CA. Katsambekis G. 2017, The Populist Surge in Post-Democratic Times: Theoretical and
Political Challenges, in “The Political Quarterly” 88 [2]: pp. 202-210.
Kennedy J. 2019, How Populists Spread Vaccine Fear, in “Politico” May 07 2019.
https://www.politico.eu/article/how-populists-spread-vaccine-fear/ (10.10. 2021). Klinger U. and Svensson J. 2015, The Emergence of Network Media Logic in Political Communication: A Theoretical Approach, in “New Media & Society” 17 [8], pp.
-1257.
Laclau E. 2005a, On Populist Reason, Verso, London.
Laclau E. 2005b, Populism: What’s in a Name?, in Panizza F. (ed.) Populism and The
Mirror of Democracy, Verso, London, pp. 32-49.
Lahsen M. 2013, Anatomy of Dissent: A Cultural Analysis of Climate Skepticism, in
“American Behavioral Scientist” 57 [6], pp. 732-753.
Lakoff G. 2006, Thinking Points. Communicating Our American Values and Vision,
Farrar, Straus and Giroux, New York, NY.
Lakoff G. 2008, The Contemporary Theory of Metaphor, in Ortony A. (ed.) Metaphor and
Thought, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 202-251.
Lakoff G. 2014, The All New Don’t Think of An Elephant! Know Your Values and Frame
the Debate, Chelsea Green Publishing, White River Junction, VT.
Lakoff G. 2016, Moral Politics. How Liberals and Conservatives Think, The University of
Chicago Press, Chicago, IL.
Lakoff G. and Johnson M. 1980, Metaphors We Live By, University of Chicago Press,
Chicago, IL.
Lee M.J. 2006, The Populist Chameleon: The People's Party, Huey Long, George
Wallace, and the Populist Argumentative Frame, in “Quarterly Journal of Speech”
[4], pp. 355-378.
Li J. and Su M.-H. 2020, Real Talk About Fake News: Identity Language and
Disconnected Networks of the US Public’s “Fake News” Discourse on Twitter, in
“Social Media+Society” 6 [2], pp. 1-14.
Lilleker D., Coman I.A., Gregor M. and Novelli E. (eds.) 2020, Political Communication
and COVID-19. Governance and Rhetoric in Times of Crisis, Routledge, London. Lorenzetti M.I. 2016, Crafting an Effective Message for the Masses, or the Art of
Populism: An Analysis of New Populist Rhetoric from a Textual Perspective, in Degani M., Frassi P. and Lorenzetti M.I. (eds.) The Languages of Politics/La politique et ses langages vol.1, Cambridge Scholars Publishing, Newcastle upon Tyne, pp. 125-157.
Lorenzetti M.I. 2018, A Cross-linguistic Study of New Populist Language, in Kranert M. and Horan G. (eds.) Doing Politics. Discursivity, Performativity and Mediation in Political Discourse, John Benjamins, Amsterdam, pp. 153-177.
Lorenzetti M.I. 2020, Anti-Immigration Rhetoric in Italy and in the USA: A Comparative Perspective, in Demata M. and Mariano M. (eds.) Anglo-American Relations in the Age of Globalization: Risks and Opportunities, Collane@unito, Torino, pp. 97-121.
Margulies B. 2019, Understanding Boris Johnson’s Appeal: Performative Rebelliousness, Impishness, and Indiscipline, in “LSE British Politics and Policy Blog”. https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/politicsandpolicy/the-appeal-of-boris-johnson/ (10.10.2021).
Merkley E. and Loewen P.J. 2021, Anti-intellectualism and the Mass Public’s Response to the COVID-19 Pandemic, in “Nature Human Behaviour” 5, pp. 706-715.
MetaNet, University of California, Berkeley. https://metanet.icsi.berkeley.edu/metanet/
Mintrom M, Rublee M.R., Bonotti M. and Zech S.T. 2021, Policy Narratives, Localisation, and Public Justification: Responses to COVID-19, in “Journal of European Public Policy” 28 [8], pp. 1219-1237.
Mitroff I. 2004, Crisis Leadership, Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, NJ.
Moffitt B. 2015, How to Perform Crisis: A Model for Understanding the Key Role of
Crisis in Contemporary Populism, in “Government and Opposition” 50 [2], pp. 189-
Moffitt B. 2016, The Global Rise of Populism. Performance, Political Style and
Representation, Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA.
Mondon A. and Winter A. 2020. Reactionary Democracy. How Racism and the Populist
Far Right Became Mainstream, Verso, London.
Motta M. 2018, The Dynamics and Political Implications of Anti-Intellectualism in the
United States, in “American Politics Research” 46 [3], pp. 465-498.
Mudde C. 2004, The Populist Zeitgeist, in “Government and Opposition” 39 [3], pp. 541-
Mudde C. 2017, Populism: An Ideational Approach, in Rovira Kaltwasser C., Taggart P.,
Ochoa Espejo P. and Ostiguy P. (eds.) The Oxford Handbook of Populism, Oxford
University Press, Oxford, pp. 27-47.
Mudde C. 2019, The Far Right Today, Polity, London.
Mudde C. 2020, Will the Coronavirus ‘Kill Populism’? Don’t Count on It, in “The
Guardian”, March 27 2020. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/mar/
/coronavirus-populism-trump-politics-response (10.10.2021).
Mudde C. and Rovira Kaltwasser C. 2017, Populism. A Very Short Introduction, Oxford
University Press, Oxford.
Mueller J. 1970, Presidential Popularity from Truman to Johnson in “American Political
Science Review” 64 [1], pp. 18-34.
Nuñez Garcia Sauco A. 2020, Old and New Order, in Gardini G.L. (ed.) The World Before
and After COVID-19. Intellectual Reflections on Politics, Diplomacy and International Relations, European Institute of International Studies Press, Salamanca, pp. 7-10.
Olza I., Koller V., Ibarretxe-Antuñano I., Pérez-Sobrino P. and Semino E. 2021, The #ReframeCovid Initiative. From Twitter to Society via Metaphor, in “Metaphor and the Social World” 11[1], pp. 98-120.
Ostiguy P. and Roberts F. 2016, Putting Trump in Comparative Perspective: Populism and the Politicization of the Sociocultural Low, in “The Brown Journal of World Affairs” XXIII [1], pp. 25-50.
Oxford English Dictionary (OED) 2022, Oxford University Press, Oxford. https://www.oed.com/
Panizza F. 2005, Introduction: Populism and the Mirror of Democracy, in F. Panizza (ed.) Populism and The Mirror of Democracy, Verso, London, pp.1-31.
Papaioannou K., Pantazi M. and van Prooijen J-V. 2022, An Arena of Angry Minds? Unravelling the Relationship between Populism and Belief in Conspiracy Theories: The Role of Cynicism, Powerlessness, and Zero-Sum Thinking, in “POPULISMUS” Working Papers 13. http://www.populismus.gr.
Pickering M. 2001, Stereotyping: The Politics of Representation, Palgrave Macmillan, London.
Ritzer A. and Dean P. 2015, Globalization. A Basic Text, Blackwell, Chichester.
Ross A.S. and Rivers D.J. 2018, Discursive Deflection: Accusation of “Fake News” and the Spread of Mis- and Dis-Information in the Tweets of President Trump, in “Social Media + Society” 4 [2], pp. 1-12.
Ross A.S. and Rivers D.J. 2020, Donald Trump, Legitimisation and a New Political
Rhetoric, in “World Englishes” 39 [130], pp. 623-637.
Semino E. 2021, “Not Soldiers but Fire Fighters” – Metaphors and Covid-19, in “Health
Communication” 36 [1], pp. 50-58.
Snowden F.M. 2019, Epidemics and Society: From the Black Death to the Present, Yale
University Press, New Haven, CT.
Stavrakakis Y. 2014, The Return of ‘the People’: Populism and Anti-Populism in the
Shadow of the European Crisis, in “Constellations” 21, pp. 505-517.
Stavrakakis Y. and Katsambekis G. (eds.) 2020. Populism and the Pandemic: A Collaborative Report 7, in “POPULISMUS Interventions”.
http://www.populismus.gr/interventions/.
Strömbäck J. 2008, Four Phases of Mediatizaton: An Analysis of the Mediatization of
Politics, in “Journal of Press/Politics” 13 [3], pp. 228-246.
Sutton R.M. and Douglas K.M. 2020, Conspiracy Theories and the Conspiracy Mindset:
Implications for Political Ideology, in “Current Opinion in Behavioral Sciences” 34,
pp. 118-122.
Taggart P. 2000, Populism, Open University Press, Buckingham.
Taggart P. 2002, Populism and the Pathology of Representative Politics, in Mény Y. and
Surel Y. (eds.) Democracies and the Populist Challenge, Palgrave Macmillan,
London, pp. 62-80.
Timsit A. 2021, British Government’s Early Pandemic Response was a Historic Public
Health Failure, Lawmakers Say, in “The Washington Post” October 12 2021. https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2021/10/12/uk-coronavirus-pandemic-response-
historic-mistakes-inquiry/ (12.10.2021).
Trump’s Twitter Archive. https://www.thetrumparchive.com/ (22.10.2021).
van Aelst P. Shaefer T. and Stanyer J. 2012, The Personalization of Mediated Political
Communication: A Review of Concepts, Operationalizations and Key Findings, in
“Journalism” 13 [2], pp. 203-220.
van Dijk T. 1993, Principles of Critical Discourse Analysis, in “Discourse & Society” 4
, pp. 249-283.
van Dijk T. 2001, Critical Discourse Analysis, in Tannen D., Hamilton H.E. and Schiffrin
D. (eds). The Handbook of Discourse Analysis, Blackwell, London, pp. 352-371.
van Dijk T. 2002, Discourse and Racism, in Goldberg D.T. and Solomos J. (eds.) A
Companion to Racial and Ethnic Studies, Blackwell, London, pp. 145-159.
van Dijk T. 2006, Discourse and Manipulation, in “Discourse & Society” 17 [2], pp. 359-
van Dijk T. 2013, Ideology and Discourse, in Freeden M., Tower Sargent L. and Stears M.
(eds.) The Oxford Handbook of Political Ideologies, Oxford University Press,
Oxford, pp. 175-196.
van Leeuwen T. 2008, Discourse and Practice. New Tools for Critical Analysis, Oxford
University Press, Oxford.
van Leeuwen T. and Wodak R. 1999, Legitimizing Immigration Control: A Discourse-
Historical Analysis, in “Discourse Studies” 1 [1], pp. 83-118.
van Zoonen L. 2012, I-Pistemology: Changing Truth Claims in Popular and Political
Culture, in “European Journal of Communication” 27 [1], pp. 56-67.
WHO 2020, https://www.who.int/news-room/q-a-detail/herd-immunity-lockdowns-and-
covid-19 (10.10.2021).
WHO 2022a, https://covid19.who.int/ (13.06.2022).
WHO 2022b, Global Excess Deaths Associated with COVID-19, January 2020-December 2021, https://www.who.int/data/stories/global-excess-deaths-associated-with-covid- 19-january-2020-december-2021 (05.05.2022).
Wodak R. 2015, The Politics of Fear. What Right-Wing Populist Discourses Mean, SAGE, London.
Wondreys J. and Mudde C. 2020. Victims of the Pandemic? European Far-Right Parties and Covid-19, in “Nationalities Paper” 50 [1], pp. 86-103.
Wung L., Morstatter F., Carley K.M. and Liu H. 2019, Misinformation in Social Media: Definition, Manipulation, and Detection, in “ACM SIGKDD Explorations Newsletter” 21 [2], pp. 80-90.
Yong E. 2020, The U.K.’s Coronavirus ‘Herd Immunity’ Debacle, in “The Atlantic” March 16 2020. https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2020/03/coronavirus- pandemic-herd-immunity-uk-boris-johnson/608065/ (10.10.2021).
Zappettini F. and Krzyżanowski M. 2019. The Critical Juncture of Brexit in Media & Political Discourses: from National-Populist Imaginary to Cross-National Social and Political Crisis, in “Critical Discourse Studies” 16 [4], pp. 381-388.
Zaslove A. 2008, Here to Stay? Populism as a New Party Type, in “European Review” 16 [3], pp. 319 – 336.
Full Text: PDF
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
