Email this article Polar contagion. Ecogothic anxiety across media in the twenty-first century
Abstract
Concerns about climate change have seen increased attention across virtually all media after 2000. In addition to raising ecological awareness, these concerns have inspired numerous gothic fictions, in which the polar thaw consequent on global warming becomes a source of paranoia, fear and horror. This article explores a specific group of twenty-first-century cultural products that associate polar melting with epidemics triggered by pathogens or infectious insects released after lying dormant in the ice. Often called “zombie” viruses or bacteria, these pathogens appear in a wide range of fictions as well as in sensational articles that use gothic paraphernalia to describe the spread of terrible diseases. Like spectres, these agents of contagion return from the past to haunt the present; they also cast a dark shadow upon the future, as they become the invisible protagonists of “dystopian ecological visions” in which humankind and other species are at risk of annihilation. Four types of products are analysed to demonstrate that they convey similar anxieties by combining images of environmental disaster with pandemics. Different though they are in genre and medium, novels like Thaw’s Hammer (2010), films like The Thaw (2009) and TV series like Fortitude (2015-18) not only interrogate the epistemological limits of science; they also shed light onto dangerous socioeconomic dynamics while posing ethical dilemmas about the human meddling with nature. Mostly produced before the spread of coronavirus, these fictions are made more appealing by the current pandemic, which has encouraged speculation over new potential sources of contagion. Their appeal is confirmed by the 2020 proliferation of newspaper/magazine articles focusing on “zombie” pathogens. By merging objectivity with sensationalism, these articles turn pathogens into spectral agents that seek revenge for human crimes against nature.
References
Allen Edel n.d., in ANCAN. https://ancan.org/team/allen-edel/ (09.12.20).
Altschuler S. 2017, The Gothic Origins of Global Health, in “American Literature” 89 [3], pp. 557-590. DOI: 10.1215/00029831-4160894.
Botting F. 1996, Gothic, Routledge, London/New York.
Cockburn H. 2020, Climate Crisis: Thawing Arctic Permafrost Could Release Deadly Waves of Ancient Diseases, Scientists Suggest, in “Independent” (4 July 2020). https://www.independent.co.uk/environment/permafrost-release-diseases-virus-bacteria-arctic-climate-crisis-a9601431.html (07.12.20).
Costantini M. 2006, The Lure of “The Frozen Deep”: Nineteenth-Century Variations of a Gothic Trope, in “RSV. Rivista di Studi Vittoriani” 22, pp. 7-43.
Costantini M. 2020, Pandemics, Power and Conspiracy Theories, in Groom N. and Hughes W. (eds.), Special Issue: CoronaGothic: Cultures of the Pandemic, “Critical Quarterly” 62 [4], pp. 24-31.
Donnelly L. 2015, Prince Charles: Tend Our Planet like a Sick Patient, in “The Telegraph” (25 February 2015). https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/prince-charles/11435260/Prince-Charles-tend-our-planet-like-a-sick-patient.html (04.12.20).
Edel A. 2016, Thaw’s Hammer, CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform, n.p.
Fortitude (2015). Season 1. Directed by S. Miller [DVD]. Fifty Fathoms, Tiger Aspect Productions/Warner Home Video, Manchester/Burbank.
Fortitude (2017). Season 2. Directed by S. Miller [DVD]. Fifty Fathoms, Tiger Aspect Productions/Warner Home Video, Manchester/Burbank.
FreddysFingers n.d., The Thaw Review, in Horror Society. https://www.horrorsociety.com/2010/04/05/the-thaw-review/ (09.12.20).
Harvey C. 2020, “Zombie” Viruses: Can They Escape the Thawing Arctic?, in “E&E News” (14 April 2020). https://www.eenews.net/stories/1062865779 (06.12.20).
Henning R., Jonasson A.-K and Degerman P. 2018, Introduction. Nordic Narratives of Nature and the Environment, in Henning R., Jonasson A.-K. and Degerman P. (eds.), Nordic Narratives of Nature and the Environment. Ecocritical Approaches to Northern European Literatures and Cultures, Lexington Books, Lanham/Boulder/New York, pp. 1-18.
Koistinen A.K. and Mäntymäki H. 2020, Affective Estrangement and Ecological Destruction in TV Crime Series Fortitude, in Piipponen M., Mäntymäki H. and Rodi-Risberg M. (eds.), Transnational Crime Fiction. Mobility, Borders and Detection, Palgrave Macmillan, Cham, pp. 261-277.
Kristeva J. 1982, Powers of Horror. An Essay on Abjection, trans. Roudiez L.S., Columbia University Press, New York.
LaFauci L.E. 2018, “The Safest Place on Earth”: Cultural Imaginaries of Safety in Scandinavia, in Henning R., Jonasson A.-K. and Degerman P. (eds.), Nordic Narratives of Nature and the Environment. Ecocritical Approaches to Northern European Literatures and Cultures, Lexington Books, Lanham/Boulder/New York, pp. 21-37.
Lanone C. 2013, Monsters of the Ice and Global Warming: from Mary Shelley and Sir John Franklin to Margaret Atwood and Dan Simmons, in Smith A. and Hughes W. (eds.), EcoGothic, Manchester University Press, Manchester, pp. 28-43.
McCall R. 2020, Melting Glaciers and Thawing Permafrost Could Release Ancient Viruses Locked Away for Thousands of Years, in “Newsweek” (2 June 2020). https://www.newsweek.com/melting-glaciers-thawing-permafrost-ancient-viruses-1486037 (07.12.20).
Milman O. 2018, Ex-Nasa Scientist: 30 Years on, World Is Failing “Miserably” to Address Climate Change, in “The Guardian” (19th June 2018). https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/jun/19/james-hansen-nasa-scientist-climate-change-warning (04.12.20).
Reifschneider M. n.d., Thaw, The – 3,5/5, in “Blood Brothers Reviews”. https://www.bloodbrothersfilms.com/2010/01/thaw-355.html (09.12.20).
Schreiber M. 2020, The Next Pandemic Could Be Hiding in the Arctic Permafrost, in “TNR” (2 April 2020). https://newrepublic.com/article/157129/next-pandemic-hiding-arctic-permafrost(06.12.20).
Schwägerl C. 2014, The Anthropocene. The Human Era and How It Shapes Our Planet, trans. Renner Jones L., Synergetic Press, Santa Fe.
Seabrook J. 2000, Nobrow: The Culture of Marketing, the Marketing of Culture, Alfred A. Knopf, New York.
Smith A. and Hughes W. 2013, Introduction: Defining the EcoGothic, in Smith A. and Hughes W. (eds.), EcoGothic, Manchester University Press, Manchester, pp. 1-14.
The Thaw (2009). Directed by M.A. Lewis. [DVD]. Anagram Pictures Inc., Vancouver.
Thomson J. 2020, Will the Next Great Pandemic Come from the Permafrost?, in “The Narwhal” (10 April 2020). https://thenarwhal.ca/next-great-pandemic-permafrost/ (06.12.20).
Full Text: PDF
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
